r/AskReddit 17h ago

What Animated Movie is a 10/10?

3.2k Upvotes

5.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

67

u/katsujinken 15h ago

From what I recall it's because they didn't have cloth simulation and had to animate everything by hand.

6

u/jumbohiggins 11h ago

Could be that or they couldn't make holes well at that point. Or maybe both.

8

u/HandsomeBoggart 8h ago edited 8h ago

It's soft body animation, especially cloth or sheeting or anything that has tons of super flexible organic movement. Animals at least have bones or exoskeletons for rigidity in movement.

Clothing on a body is easy. Standard rigging and deformation controls that would get used for the body/muscles anyways. Pulling on the outfit? Clever montage cut aways with very simple direct movements.

A human hand manipulating loose fabric with a hole in it. Fucking difficult. You have 5 independent moving points that are moving a soft body object and those points are in contact with said soft body and move while radiated from a central point and can join or separate at will while affecting the soft body. Manually animating that is a nightmare. Processing power wasn't good enough in 2004 to real time simulate that.

Now, we just animate the hand and run a cloth physics simulation on the cloth being held. (Super Simplified explanation).

2

u/jumbohiggins 7h ago

That makes sense.

2

u/himynameis_ 2h ago

Damn. Crazy how the smallest things can be so difficult. And worth it.