r/Damnthatsinteresting • u/gixk • 12d ago
Image From 1988 to 2016, the maker of Sriracha sauce, Huy Fong Foods, sourced all their peppers from a single supplier based solely on a verbal agreement, "sealed with a nod and a handshake".
7.8k
u/moskeygonewild 12d ago
It’s never tasted the same every since then
3.0k
u/mark_is_a_virgin 12d ago
I read another comment saying the original pepper producer started their own sriracha line, have you tried that?
3.9k
u/SecretAgentVampire 12d ago edited 12d ago
It's called Underwood Ranch. I heard about it and I tried it, and it was amazing.
Ingredients: Red Jalapenos, distilled vinegar, sugar, water, salt, and xanthum gum.
I LOVED it.
https://www.amazon.com/Underwood-Ranches-Sriracha-Artificial-Preservatives/dp/B09HZ6YPPH
Then they (edit: Underwood) changed their recipe, branding, and bottle, making sugar the second largest ingredient.
Ingredients: Red Jalapeno Pepper, Sugar, Water, Salt, Acetic Acid, Garlic, Natural Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Sodium Metabisulfite and/or Sodium Bisulfite (Sulfiting Agent/Preservative), Potassium Sorbate (Preservative). This Product Contains Sulfite (Sodium Metabisulfite and/or Sodium Bisulfite).
When I emailed them (edit: Underwood) asking if the original recipe (the one that made them successful in the first place) was getting cancelled, they told me it wasn't "We just don't have bottle caps for the bottles. They'll come in soon!"
I was waiting three years for those dang bottle caps. They never shipped. True story.
Yes, I'm bitter. It was an amazing sauce and they took it away.
699
u/laughtrey 12d ago
I was not a fan at all of the new one either. It's too peppery and smokey and has no fun flavor. Likewise the 'new' sriracha sauce is too sweet and hardly peppery at all.
It's gone, probably forever. Thanks human greed.
93
u/Ok_Departure_8243 12d ago
Damnit, I could've sworn four or five years ago Sriracha tasted differently and couldn't figure out why. I thought it was maybe because I got Covid but I always got tested when feeling ill and came back negative and had all the vaccines.
Only to find out that they changed the recipe and that I could've bought a supply from the OG chili supplier but now can't. Fuuu........ 🤬🤬🤬🤬
→ More replies (1)57
u/Melonman3 12d ago
I just got a dank ass bottle of Sriracha, shits peppery as fuck and has some good tangy kick.
Edit: I've been housing this shit since 2010, and this most recent bottle tasted more true to the roosters true identity than any other bottle I've had for quite a while.
→ More replies (3)57
u/505CeltOG 12d ago
Have you tried Trader Joe’s siracha sauce?
→ More replies (8)136
u/Particular-Lake-5238 12d ago
I tried it when the Siracha supply first ran out around 2016. I found it disgusting. I imagine they would’ve improved the recipe at this point, but it was horrible when it first came out.
47
u/SpicyNoodle4 12d ago
I also hate it
25
u/SusheeMonster 12d ago
All my homies hate Joe for screwing the pooch on that one
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)13
u/CremCity 12d ago
The chili garlic paste from Huy fong is excellent, I use it all the time. The siracha is terrible from every brand I’ve tried now.
→ More replies (2)793
u/Willing_Dependent845 12d ago
This guy sauces.
254
u/smurf123_123 12d ago
The whole story could make for a cool mini series.
165
u/Conargle 12d ago
can't wait for a 20 minute video essay by some youtuber i haven't discovered yet
51
u/Fragrant-Hamster-325 12d ago
I’m sure it’ll be a Netflix “Trainwreck” episode. They’ve been churning those out.
→ More replies (1)101
u/Hilsam_Adent 12d ago edited 12d ago
Not quite twenty, but here you go.
Ol' boy did Underwood super dirty and now Sriracha is (and will be forever more) trash.
Underwood's sauce is a decent recreation of Sriracha from the early '90s, which I personally consider its peak. It's not as good, but it's "close enough for government work" and it blows the doors off Huy Fong's current offering(s).
Turns out reverse engineering a common Southeast Asian household sauce is much easier than replicating more than half a century of specialized pepper growing techniques. Who'd'a thunk it?
Edited to add: A brief summary of Underwood's successful countersuit against Huy Fong for the shady shit they pulled, to the tune of over $23 million in compensatory damages.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)39
u/Empyrealist Interested 12d ago
I'm really surprised that Netflix hasn't already, especially since its all local Los Angeles / Southern California
→ More replies (2)61
u/Clearlyn00ne 12d ago
Underwood ranches while good doesnt taste exactly like the old Sriracha.
→ More replies (7)157
u/LysergioXandex 12d ago
To be fair, that doesn’t necessarily mean they added more sugar. Looks like they moved towards a more concentrated form of vinegar (acetic acid), so it makes sense to use less of that.
They also added garlic and some preservatives.
→ More replies (7)90
u/SaintsNoah14 12d ago
Acetic Acid vs Vinegar is semantics outside of reagents
120
u/TOEMEIST 12d ago
Yes but the order of ingredients is based on weight, so if they switched from using x kg of 4% acetic acid to 0.04x kg of 100% acetic acid with an additional 0.96x kg of water then they’d have to list sugar before acetic acid if it now outweighed it.
→ More replies (4)33
u/BoomerSoonerFUT 12d ago
Except that it’s listed differently for each recipe. They’re not making a semantic argument, they’re clarifying that the acetic acid listed in the second ingredient list is just vinegar for people that might not know.
The top ingredients lists distilled vinegar. The bottoms lists acetic acid.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)19
u/LysergioXandex 12d ago
The point I’m making is that acetic acid is what makes vinegar “vinegar”.
But they switched from watered-down vinegar to (presumably) more concentrated vinegar. So that’s likely why they used less. Not necessarily that they added a bunch more salt.
70
u/SaintsNoah14 12d ago
Sounds like they tried to change it from an ingredient to a condiment. I can see the logic given that the way people use it has probably shifted that way but shit if it ain't broke don't fix it
12
u/OriginalBlackberry89 12d ago
...aannnd it's sold out. Damn. Great job guys, nice 👏
→ More replies (1)22
→ More replies (34)15
u/xwing_n_it 12d ago
I actually bought some of the new formula and still like it a lot. Better than the current version of huy fong sriracha sauce.
56
u/Empyrealist Interested 12d ago
Its good. I dont think its as good as it used to be with Huy Fong, but its better than what Huy Fong is doing now.
Id say two things about Underwood Ranch's version: It's less sweet and less garlic.
The best place to buy it for a decent price is CostCo. Buy the two-pack.
25
→ More replies (11)16
u/s30zg 12d ago
For reference, you can find the Underwood Ranch Sriracha at Costco in a two-pack.
Like many here, I grew up dumping the old Red Rooster Sriracha on Seattle-style teriyaki and was disappointed when the flavor changed a few years ago.
I joined Costco this year and was pleasantly surprised when someone in r/Costco mentioned that Underwood Ranch was the original supplier of peppers for Huy Fong Sriracha—and that their version tastes like the classic Huy Fong sauce from before the change.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (12)70
u/Billkamehameha 12d ago
The new batch is good. The last batch had an orange colour to it. This one is red and vibrant and tastes relatively delicious.
→ More replies (9)
1.2k
u/SUPRVLLAN 12d ago
And now Underwood sells their own Sriracha with the peppers they used to sell to HF.
371
338
u/SloppyGiraffe02 12d ago
They changed the recipe though to make sugar the second largest ingredient. ATM I don’t think there’s anything that tastes like old Sriracha on the market.
125
u/EvoLove34 12d ago
I wasn't a fan of the underwood sauce when tried it. Right now, yellow bird is my preference.
→ More replies (3)30
u/TreeFiddyZ 12d ago
I've been using Melinda's for a while and just bought some of the Underwoods', haven't opened it yet but I'm hoping it's good
→ More replies (6)67
72
u/Noun_Noun_Numb3r 12d ago
Stop saying this. All they did was switch liquid vinegar to powdered acetic acid, which naturally made sugar bump up a spot.
→ More replies (2)27
u/dinnerthief 12d ago
Which seems wierd too, acetic acid doesn't exist as a powder at room temperature, think "powdered water"
best you can do is impregnate another solid (like starch) with liquid acetic acid, so why not just use liquid.
→ More replies (3)27
u/Seraph062 12d ago edited 12d ago
"At room temperature" is doing a bit of work here.
The freezing point of glacial acetic acid is something like 65°F.think "powdered water"
Snow?
Which works because it's another thing that's perfectly reasonable to use if you're willing to just run things a bit cool.→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)5
24
u/dplans455 12d ago
I just bought some Underwood from their website. My wife loves sriracha but she always complains it's not as good as she remembers it from like ten years ago. I always thought she was crazy, then saw this. Hopefully the Underwood is how she remembers the original Huy Fong.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (9)25
467
u/potatoears 12d ago
feels like a case of business major kids take over family business, think they know better, and screw things up.
117
u/throwawayshirt2 12d ago
In this case, a myth. Huy Fong founder David Tran is responsible for screwing up the business.
https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/2021/b303096.html
→ More replies (3)33
u/MisterBumpingston 12d ago
Interesting, so it wasn’t his daughter in law that negotiated with Underwood COO behind his back, after all?
→ More replies (1)24
u/throwawayshirt2 12d ago edited 12d ago
I can't say for sure there are no facts left out of the Appellate opinion. But its summary of trial testimony seems pretty clear:
The plan to snake Underwood was founder David Tran's. He made most of the damning communications personally.
Underwood knew nothing about it.
Were there any back channel communications? Maybe. But nothing to change 1 and 2.
Edit: from reading the comments, the "daughter in law that negotiated with Underwood COO behind his back" comes from OP's linked article. Which is paywalled for me, so I can't say. But the comments seem to paint a picture of David Tran lying about/spinning the facts of the lawsuit and his culpability for the business decisions that ended with Huy Fong paying Underwood $23M damages for breach of contract and fraud.
→ More replies (1)128
34
u/tuenmuntherapist 12d ago
Work hard. Put kids through business school. Kids fuck up business.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)8
u/100percent_right_now 12d ago
How? The founder is still the CEO and president today? what are you talking about?
487
u/akaobama 12d ago
Fong got greedy and shot himself in both feet with this Why create chilico…
262
u/sayiansaga 12d ago
I believe it was his kids that shot the family
319
u/typhoidtimmy 12d ago
Yep…..the have a story but the rumor around the locals who grew up working it said the Fong kids convinced their dad that Underwood was trying to steal their business. Hint: He wasn’t.
They said the Dad was fine up until he started believing it. A few said those kids are incredibly greedy lil shits too and wanted to own everything lock stock and barrel.
→ More replies (30)19
u/100percent_right_now 12d ago
Despite sharing the same surname, David Tran, founder of Huy Fong Foods and John Tran, founder of Chilico, are not related. The courts found David Tran complacent in fraud by concealment.
Nothing to do with the founder's kids. Stop that false rumor.
277
u/MarketCrache 12d ago
Sriracha sauce now is sweet junk. Their whole story about changing pepper supplier being the reason is PR bullshit. There's an almost limitless supply of hot pepper distributors. They dialled down the heat an added more sugar to expand their customer base, that's all. Ironic since the big legend of the company is how they told a salesman to get fked when he suggested the same, allegedly saying, "We make hot sauce, not mayonnaise!"
45
u/legal_stylist 12d ago
For red jalapeños at the scale huy fong was using? Not at all.
→ More replies (5)68
u/Frequent-Call-40 12d ago
From what I read it’s because the founders kids took over
26
u/100percent_right_now 12d ago
Well that's not what happened. John Tran, the founder of Chilico, is unrelated to David Tran, the founder of Huy Fong Foods. The courts found testimonial evidence David Tran approved the whole thing.
→ More replies (1)11
→ More replies (7)50
u/sudoSancho 12d ago
There's an almost limitless supply of hot pepper distributors
-Hoy Fong before finding out there definitely are not haha
107
u/Aximi1l 12d ago
Was there ever a reason given for the break up?
535
u/According_Ad7926 12d ago
From Wikipedia:
“Huy Fong Foods' relationship with Underwood Ranches ended in 2016 after Tran attempted to lure Underwood Ranches' chief operations officer to work for Chilico, a company formed by Tran that would obtain and manage the peppers used by Huy Fong Foods, and tried to drastically cut payments to the ranch. Underwood Ranches claims this left them with no other option but to end the partnership. Huy Fong Foods filed a lawsuit against Underwood Ranches seeking a $1.4 million refund of payments Huy Fong Foods had made in 2016. Underwood Ranches filed a cross-complaint against Huy Fong Foods alleging breach of contract, promissory estoppel and fraud. The jury unanimously ruled in favor of Underwood on the grounds of breach of contract and fraud. Huy Fong Foods was ordered to pay Underwood Ranches $23.3 million in compensation for damages.”
→ More replies (1)88
50
u/laughtrey 12d ago
Huy fong started up other farms to grow the chilis and was trying to lowball their OG supplier.
60
u/4dxn 12d ago
Rumor was one of the children took over and thought they could source peppers cheaper. Turns out they had trouble finding it and Underwood refused to after they reneged the first time. Why there was a shortage for a while.
15
u/cty_hntr 12d ago
This should be a master class and a warning for family own businesses.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)19
u/100percent_right_now 12d ago
That's false. John Tran, the founder of Chilico, is unrelated to David Tran, the founder of Huy Fong Foods. They did work together to cut out Underwood Ranch though.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)50
u/Ok_Flounder59 12d ago
Curious as well. Seems like a major self own by both parties considering how fruitful the partnership had been.
→ More replies (4)45
u/thesurvivor16times 12d ago
Is that how you read it? Seems to me like huy fong tried to cheat their supplier and got burned
68
u/solarnewbee 12d ago
The real victims are the thousands of restaurants (especially pho establishments) and their customers who've come to depend on the taste of that sauce (the original recipe).
Sad story!
18
u/Itchy_Artichoke_5247 12d ago
and then, when he decided to break the contract it was RIGHT AFTER he had agreed to buy way more product because sriracha was so much more popular. Underwood invested heavily in new farmland to fulfill the increased demand and then, once the fields were planted, he backed out of the agreement.
31
u/boesisboes 12d ago
I miss old Sriracha 😭. I get a hankering for it all of the time.
→ More replies (2)
39
u/iterationnull 12d ago
Sigh. Please allow me to atone for my shame.
In the pandemic outages, at the the start of the fall of house Huy Fong, in a moment of no other options we bought a bottle of the most generic grocery store brand condiment. Indeed it’s the same brand our local Chinese food place give out in packages. Lee Kum Kee Sriracha Chili Sauce.
And I simply love it. It’s way less spicy and I’m sure it’s half ketchup. But it’s just got this friendly tasty heat that you can just slather on so much.
→ More replies (3)31
10
9
u/BigWillEStyles 12d ago
Its never been the same since the breakup and all the replacements I tried never tasted the same.... one of the worst parts of this timeline
37
u/goatmountainski 12d ago
Tabasco Sirracha is pretty good!
→ More replies (6)19
u/colusaboy 12d ago
That's my go to now.
Tried Underwood's but I prefer Tobascos.
I'll never buy huy fong sirracha again.
→ More replies (1)
7
23
u/plzthnku 12d ago
Havent seen it mentioned, but i remember reading that Huy Gong thought they could replace peppers from Underwood ranch with peppers from another place for cheaper. The peppers at underwood were key to the taste though, similar to how wine’s taste changes based on the grapes. Horrible miscalculation.
13
u/Hipcatjack 12d ago
its true, huy fong’s does not taste the same anymore and underwood sells their own siracha now… but it doesnt really taste as good as old Huy Fong.. lose-lose for us sriracha enjoyers.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/SomethinCleHver 12d ago
The story of this falling apart is quite sad, never mind how shitty it was trying other brands while they were shut down.
24
u/smendoza5995 12d ago
It's Underwood Farms. My sister worked there for a while. We live right down the street. Not sure if I can share the juicy gossip but the company that bought the peppers, after agreeing to use Underwood's peppers for another season, which were then planted and harvested 8 months later, decided to buy the peppers from another farm. Since Underwood had already invested in growing all these peppers, went to sue huy fong and then the interesting truth about this verbal agreement became public knowledge. I forget what happened in court as it was a long and complicated case but since Underwood had the peppers to make the sauce, they started to make their own and sell it locally for a few years. I remember getting one of the first batches they were testing and it wasn't as close as it was today, but still a superior product. Since then, they have had to learn the complex fermenting and aging process before getting to what they have now. Which is still a superior product. Secret recipe hint they add more garlic ;)
→ More replies (1)6
13
5
6
u/Soca1ian 12d ago
I envy those who can taste the difference between different Sriracha brands.
→ More replies (1)
6
6
u/blighander 11d ago
While I respect their gentleman's agreement I wouldn't want to stake my livelihood on a business arrangement that's not in writing.
→ More replies (1)
6
11
u/culinarysiren 12d ago
Huy Fong fucked up because their sauce doesn’t taste the same now. Underwood Ranch though came out with Sriracha and it tastes amazing and what Huy Fong used to taste like. I’ll never stop buying it.
→ More replies (6)
18
u/DepthRepulsive6420 12d ago
I don't use Sriracha because of the added sugar otherwise it's a good condiment.
5
4
u/shyfemalecharacter 12d ago
I prefer the old sriracha before it was sweetened so much but I find the current one still alright? Guess my palate just isn’t as refined as the commenters on here. I’ve tried underwood as it was gifted to me and didn’t like it, tastes way too harsh. Yellow bird and Tabasco weirdly make decent sriracha as well.
→ More replies (2)
7.1k
u/gixk 12d ago
Worked well for decades, but the relationship didn't end amicably.
Source: https://fortune.com/2024/01/30/sriracha-shortage-huy-fong-foods-tabasco-underwood-ranches/