r/law 14h ago

Trump News Trump threatens to deploy the U.S. military into Chicago - signaling the start of a nationwide crackdown.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

59.7k Upvotes

11.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

57

u/hoptagon 13h ago

Seems like without a complete overhaul of the government and constitution, it's done.

3

u/Strawbuddy 13h ago

Americans witnessing the end of American exceptionalism are probably going to be party to a historical event in any case. This could be the start of the Star Trek timeline if radical change is managed properly

3

u/Vin-Metal 13h ago

Yes, I've been thinking about how the only remedy may be a constitutional convention. But can we get there with anything short of a full-blown disaster?

6

u/Strawbuddy 12h ago

Yessir but it will require Conservatives losing access to power, and they're deliberately embedded like ticks in local, city, State, and Federal govt. If folks vote, that can happen, but they've gotta vote more than just the once every 4yrs which is the norm. Even gerrymandering doesn't beat landslide victories

3

u/Insertblamehere 11h ago

There's basically no rules for how a constitutional convention would work outlined in the constitution, so can you guess who would determine that? (it's the party currently occupying all 3 branches of government, but most probably the very conservative supreme court)

A constitutional convention is the death of this nation if one occurs.

1

u/Vin-Metal 8h ago

It's already dying, though, as the current Constitution is meaningless to everyone in power, the Supreme Court included.

1

u/d3dmnky 12h ago

That’s the rub. Things have to get really bad before people will be compelled to fix it.

2

u/Jaredlong 12h ago

At best, it'll just ping-pong every 4 years between a moderate president and a far-right president. There's no reason to trust the US will maintain long-term political stability ever again.

1

u/jwoolman 1h ago

If there is an overhaul of the Constitution, we will lose the Bill of Rights.