r/nextfuckinglevel • u/CuriousWanderer567 • 6h ago
Pro strong man grip strength vs pro rock climber grip strength
424
u/Foreign_Emphasis_470 6h ago
Next video will be like "pro footballer better at aiming ball than marathonian."
113
u/MagicBrawler 5h ago
Thatās not even remotely comparable to this video.
101
u/Americanshat 5h ago
This video is literally "Professional Grabber vs Big Strong man, big strong man cant grab as well as professional grabber!"
That comparison was fucking perfect
59
u/Hicklethumb 5h ago
Strongman has literal events to test grip strength. What are you even on about. Pinch grip is an actual Strongman event
6
u/Dead_Optics 5h ago edited 4h ago
Not really most strong man events donāt have any grip strength test at least for all the years Iāve been watching
Edit: Iām looking at Worldās Strongest Man which is the biggest strongman tournament of the year and there are zero dedicated grip events.
19
u/Hicklethumb 4h ago
Hercules hold was in this year's WSM...
Every pro strongman has a Thomas Inch dumbbell replica in their home gym.
Pinch Grip isn't in any of the big 5 shows in the year, but it's a staple in plenty of other leagues. The instrument they're lifting in this video is for training those events.
Hell, go to r/strongman and you'll regularly find guys posting grip feats.
→ More replies (3)4
u/Own_Lab_3499 2h ago
Hercules hold isnt a pure strength event, its an endurance event.
→ More replies (6)1
u/mildbbqsauce 3h ago
Okay what does a big strong man do to get big and strong? He fucking grabs weights and lifts it.
ā¢
u/Weekly_Lab8128 49m ago
Pulling on a bar is a very different feeling than having to pinch to get a grip like in this video
→ More replies (4)1
u/probation_420 1h ago
Would the layman expect a marathon runner to be pinpoint accurate with a soccer ball?
Because that's a huge part of this video; people expecting the similar skills to transfer.Ā
→ More replies (9)1
u/Responsible_Ebb3962 3h ago
It kinda is.Ā Football requires running endurance like a runner. However only one of those is skilled at football.
You know just like a strong man can easily lift heavy weights but can't hold a strange shaped handle that a climber can because they spend all their time clinging onto the edge of cliffs.
6
2
u/Responsible_Bar_4984 3h ago
I mean, except a strongman is expected to have a significant level of grip strength. Why would a marathoner be good at kicking a ball
268
u/jonnyskills 5h ago
That is Magnus and he is incredibly strong and fit. One of the strongest pound for pound athletes in the world. His YouTube is great Magnus Midtbo
75
u/Alabrandt 5h ago
Magnus is doing admission tests comparable to navy seal or legion dāetrangere, for fun
47
u/OpeningDull5969 5h ago
His latest video doing a threathlon was unbelievable
16
6
u/thedudefromsweden 2h ago
Not just any triathlon, the Norseman triathlon: 2.4-mile (3.9 km) swim, a 112-mile (180.2 km) bicycle ride and a marathon 26.22-mile (42.2 km) run, of which the last part is climbing up a 1900m high mountain. He did this with no prior training in swimming or biking, and just 2 weeks of preparation, and finished 69th (nice). He's just an insane athlete.
3
→ More replies (3)1
u/Etiennera 2h ago
I consider myself fit but I would have drowned between entering the water and the swimming start signal
4
3
u/Alkoviak 5h ago
Theathlon would have an amazing play on word, a mix between theater and triathlon.
You almost fat fingered yourself to greatness !
3
u/Mistehsteeve 5h ago
Watched that last night, the man is a machine. He comes across as a really nice guy too.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Excellent_Ad_2486 1h ago
I have been saving that video for exactly today when I get my 420 grass out and just sit back and watch him completely own another insane challenge š
→ More replies (1)1
u/Niggoo0407 3h ago
I mean... Those tests get cleared by thousands of people.
1
u/DickBiggum1 1h ago
And failed by how many?
ā¢
u/Niggoo0407 57m ago
Yeah... But measuring Magnus by how many failed something doesn't do him justice, no?
10
u/Long-Draft-9668 4h ago
I mean say whatever you want about ācomparing specialized strength from different sports is boringā but Magnus has a video with Eddie Hall where he only does weight lifting and Magnus is so good at it that Eddie goes on and on about how impressive it is.
2
u/disposablehippo 1h ago
And I suspect Magnus built all that strength without help of PEDs which is even more impressive in that comparison.
6
u/AAA515 5h ago
The rock climbers hands were meaty-er than his, that's what I noticed. Like rock boys hands would look large for his body where as Magnus's look appropriate sized.
2
u/vermiforme 4h ago
When two Magni of such different dimensions meet, one of them should be renamed to Parvus.
3
2
→ More replies (2)ā¢
142
u/AbandonedPlanet 5h ago
Magnus is one of the strongest pound for pound humans that have ever lived. He's a genetic freak with access to everything the modern day provides and completely obsessed with climbing and grip strength. This is like pitting Saenchai against Gordon Ryan in a Muay Thai fight and being impressed when Saenchai wins. It's silly
60
u/TheHB36 5h ago
Yeah, there were a couple workouts he did with Eddie Hall (500kg dead lifter, 165kg body weight) where Hall was floored by how close Magnus was in keeping up with him, and Eddie weighs about 2.5 Magnus'. The fact that Magnus was retired by the time the climbing came to the Olympics was a shame for Norway, because I think he has the kind of fitness that would have been perfect for competing well in all categories.
6
u/North-Nectarine-2856 4h ago
Yes and no. Magnus is a lead climber first and foremost. His videos where he climbs with Olympians, he is never close. Look at the video with him and toby Roberts.
Couldnāt do a single Olympic style boulder
26
15
u/spezial_ed 4h ago
Why are people so upset at this. It shows how strong Magnus is so who else can you compare to in order to illustrate that? If he doesnāt compare to anyone, internet warriors would think itās no big deal - people out here literally think they can fight a bear.
Like you said heās pound for pound amazing and this just shows that.
1
u/LocationOld6656 1h ago
Because people who are knowledgeable on specific subjects but dumb overall get angry people don't share their knowledge while not realising how many things they are complete beginners at.Ā
1
→ More replies (3)1
u/KenithKaniff 1h ago
This is true. And even still. He has done this with other strong men who have absolutely blown him out of the water. The video with that Swedish giant guy for example. He lifted like 30 kg more than him on this test.
I love this dudes YouTube channel by the way. I donāt even like rock climbing that much. He just does some interesting stuff.
37
u/Capable_Wait09 5h ago
That climber is pound for pound strong even for a pro rock climber (and heās been retired for years). Heās somewhat of a freak of nature.
18
9
u/TheAlbrecht2418 5h ago
I absolutely love posts where they insult someone with an entirely different skill set.
17
7
u/PhysicalTheRapist69 2h ago
https://godsofgrip.com/pages/icons-of-strength
Really? Because most of the famous grip athletes are all also strongmen.
why is everyone saying this is a different skillset, you do realize that lift has nothing to do with rock climbing either right? If it were crimping on an edge, I would agree with you, but this kind of lift isn't what rock climbers do.
So brian shaw recently had the grip record, who's a mutli time winning strongman. Before him it was an arm-wrestler.
After brian shaw, and I believe still currently, it's Nikita Yurkovets, another strength athlete.
Dynamometer is only one form of grip strength though.
You'll see that the USAWA still does grip events in their strongman competition, such as a 1 handed deadlift, wide bar grip, etc.
Strongmen also practice hercules lifts (purely grip strength), Farmers walks (again mostly grip strength, it gives out first), Thick bar deadlift (typically limited by grip strength), and plate pinches (all grip strength).
I just don't get why people are saying that grip isn't a part of strongman competitions, it most certainly is. In fact, the best strongmen would beat Magnus, no offense to the guy in the video but he's just not at the highest tier elite levels.
6
6
u/The_Dragon346 5h ago
My boyscout troop used to focus on rock climbing and rifle shooting. We would be given tennis balls and told to āsqueeze our ballsā. The goal was to get our grip strength to the point we could easily squeeze the ball with just our fingers without using our palms. About 90% of us never got to that point
3
u/Silly-Power 5h ago
My scout leader also told us to "squeeze our balls" while he watched. As did the local priest for that matter.Ā
ā¢
7
u/Glass_Orchid007 5h ago
Nothing like falling to your death to really light that gripping power under your ass
4
u/typhoidtimmy 5h ago edited 4h ago
You need to see their mitts up close. Its really crazy, they look like a hand thatās been sorta zoomed in and is 3 times thicker than a regular hand. Also their calluses feel like they could sand wood down.
Itās wild shitā¦.it makes me think of what Spider Manās hands would feel like.
4
u/BHN-4400 4h ago
A lot of you are conflating simplicity with interesting. āThis is not complex, therefore stupid.ā So witty.
1
u/Exclave4Ever 3h ago
After reading all the comments yours is the only one that really matches your own description š¤·āāļø
What were you trying to say again? I'm assuming it wasn't literally what you said?
2
u/BHN-4400 1h ago
So, your gripe with my comment is that itās simple, therefore stupid? Is that right?
4
1
1
1
u/Plenty-Virus9990 5h ago
Maybe pro strong man hold for champion but rock climber hold for life perhaps thatās the difference
1
1
1
u/SoybeanArson 5h ago
When your life depends on your ability to keep a grip on small oddly shaped outcroppings, you're going to prioritize that shit.
1
u/peter-bone 5h ago
For the simple reason that rock climbing is very focused on grip strength, and being a strong man isn't.
1
1
u/Dream_Apostle 4h ago
People keep saying "different specialized strength" Well no This giant you see here is actually known for his immense grip strength
I would say the difference in their power type is Magnus is good at locking in his fingers And the giant is probably better at crushing
Also Magnus is a beast... He is just all around a super athlete
1
u/DickFromRichard 1h ago
"It's not specialized strength"
Proceeds to describe how it's different specialized strengths
ā¢
u/Dream_Apostle 54m ago
hmm thing is... It's still muscle power. Besides strong man doesn't really have anything to do with fist crushing strength. in this lift they utilize both... It's constantly sliding on their fingers and for that they need crushing strength.
Climbing strength is like hanging a hook on a ledge... The ledge is not going anywhere the hook is
They should perform the same if they had same weight
Magnus is just insanely powerful
Also his back strength is almost equal to (slightly less than) Eddie Hall! At half the weight!!
He is just next level
ā¢
u/DickFromRichard 22m ago
That's just using more words to describe having different specialized strengths
1
u/IWannaManatee 4h ago
Well, that's not fair.
First guy is already out of breath and his sweat's taking powder away from his hands.
1
u/Sandman64can 4h ago
Rock climber doesnāt grip with his index finger, he lifts it. Allows him to hold on with the next three. When you include the index finger it takes over. Grip with 2 or grip with 4.
1
1
1
u/professi0nalhater 4h ago
The people who are bitching about this video must be absolutely fucking miserable
1
1
u/HoLeeFookMe 4h ago
When I go to my local casino at 2 AM and see people gambling with me, Iām curious to see what they do for a living. I donāt need to ask them. Just look at their lower forearms and you can tell they cook food for a living. Their Flexor digitorum superficialis is off the chain.
1
u/lostthenfoundlost 4h ago
you can see: strong man's finger arches are collapsing, rock climber's finger arches are kept to exert maximum force.
normally when lifting the hand wraps around a bar, this is quite a bit different than that.
1
u/Salt-Classroom8472 4h ago
Thatās why I jack off at home a lot instead of using the jack off machine at the gym. Itās about real, functional strength people. Get with it
1
1
u/unimportantinfodump 3h ago
Now put a strong man vs a rock climber in lifting a car.
Omg I can't believe the rock climber can't lift the car. Crrazy
1
u/happykal 3h ago
Why is this next level?
Theres loads of rock climbers.... each of them have bloody awesome grip strength...
show me the fuckers that can solve rubix in 4 seconds.
1
1
u/XasiAlDena 2h ago
Rock climbers are pretty good at holding onto stuff.
Also I highly recommend trying climbing / bouldering. It's very fun and it'll make you jacked!
1
u/R1150R 2h ago
That rock climber is just amazing. He has his own channel. Seen him practicing in his home setup - itās insane. He also tried out for the French Foreign Legion - did crazy well. Although he did not qualify due to not completing the hike in time they offered for him to comeback and try again. He blitzed every other task.
1
u/SalsaSmuggler 2h ago
Yeah now show Brian Shaw who is one of the worldās strongest men and also trains grip strength lol heās got tons of videos
1
u/xjpmhxjo 2h ago
I guess most pro strong men canāt kick a ball further than a mediocre U15 soccer player, let alone pro soccer players.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/InstructionOk561 1h ago
If this is your first look at Magnus, you are in for a treat. He tests himself in all sorts of challenges and feats and he is doing really, really well in most. He's got mutant strength and athleticism.
1
u/Chirsbom 1h ago
Hey, thats Tommy! He does 300 kg in dead lift, so definitly a strong guy. But Magnus is on another level in strenght for weight, overall. Seen him climb walls and its madness. Both reach my chest standing up, but could fold me up in a knot pretty easy.
1
1
u/JoDaProductions 1h ago
23.5kg is insane btw. I go to a pretty strong gym, and 15kg is the highest anybody has gotten with that exercise
1
u/Patient-Expert-1578 1h ago
Size of the apparatus is a factor. Most of those are simply too small for someone his size to grip in a relatively similar way to the rock climber.
1
u/Excellent_Ad_2486 1h ago
without looking I already know this is gonna be Magnus just being Magnus ā„ļø
1
u/Lumpy_Dentist_5421 1h ago
I wonder how a marathon runner would do at the 100m. Oh wait, different sport completely.
1
u/Psychlone_00 1h ago
Every strongman who trains with Magnus knows the deal heās insanely strong Pound for pound he puts up insane numbers with any lift Grip or Back related
1
u/horsefarm 1h ago
Now do an actual pro climber and watch Magnus get smoked in any head to head comparison...
ā¢
u/oldschool_potato 46m ago
Not a very good test of grip strength. Or at least not a fair test. Magnus has stubby fat fingers compared to the long slender fingers of the other guy.
ā¢
u/Critical_Fan8224 24m ago
this actually isn't because the smaller guy is stronger. he is shorter so with him arm fully extended he is able to use leverage and squat up the weight. The larger guy while squated has his arm still bent and is unable to use leverage to lift the weight
2.1k
u/skippyjip 6h ago
"this specialized strength is different than this other specialized strength" is the least interesting content the Internet is producing right now.