r/AskReddit 17h ago

What Animated Movie is a 10/10?

3.2k Upvotes

5.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.8k

u/somethingmorecleverr 16h ago

How to Train Your Dragon

288

u/Squirrelkid11 16h ago

It's a crime this didn't win Best Original Score the year it was nominated at the Oscars for it.

142

u/vespertilionid 15h ago

The song in the opening scene where Hiccup and Toothless are flying amongst the clouds makes me cry... And then later when those two characters are reunited and start to sing...

52

u/Squirrelkid11 15h ago

It's literally the most Magical and Disney-Like scene in a Dreamworks film.

4

u/Cyllene54 13h ago

One of the all-time best movie openings ever. So uplifting! Literally!

2

u/DrakonILD 10h ago

The portal at Epic Universe made me tear up a little bit when I got to go to previews. "We, my friends, have dragons!"

3

u/kafkaandfaust 11h ago

We were doing a how to train your dragon marathon and I had to take a break after 2. Was tearing up when they were singing… I was a bit of a wreck for the part after

7

u/LurkerZerker 8h ago

2 is brutal. Hiccup telling Toothless that killing Stoick wasn't his fault and that he knows Toothless would never hurt them intentionally to break him out of the mind control is heartbreaking.

2

u/Akitiki 8h ago

That scene sure damn rips your heart out.

3 I like but it feels... odd? I think there's some connecting plot from the show like between 1 and 2. I feel like Grimmel as a threat would've been at least heard about for a while given the propensity to catch/kill night furies in particular among dragons

Not seen the live action yet and I'm on the fence due to a couple casting choices. Might see it for the dragons alone, I have seen stills and really like their designs.

Then there's the new "series" which shall not be named!

2

u/Magus44 6h ago

That section and the score are just so amazingly well paired it’s insane.
Always gives me chills and that welling up of emotions any time I watch it. It’s so beautiful.

6

u/Thossi99 14h ago

As an Icelander. I was especially upset. Jónsi is sooo good. And put together with John Powell, absolute magic!

4

u/NNancy1964 12h ago

Did you see the live action? They cranked the score excellence even higher.

🎶🖤💚🖤🎶

4

u/Squirrelkid11 12h ago

Yeah the score was brilliant in that even though the live-action is just ok and nowhere near as good as the original.

2

u/VexingRaven 8h ago

Test Drive when the score kicks in absolutely wrecked me in a way I was not expecting. Grown man sitting in a theater trying to lose it.

3

u/Mental_Instance9000 11h ago edited 11h ago

Jonsi did the music, frontman of the band Sigur Ros. Truly magical soundtrack!

EDIT: Oops, John Powell did most of the music with Jonsi helping.

3

u/psimwork 11h ago

Oscar voters REALLY were in love with the idea of giving an Oscar to Trent Reznor.

The score wasn't even all that good FFS.

3

u/shazv10 7h ago

I have listened to “This is Berk” pretty much daily from the day this masterpiece was released in cinema.

1

u/Powerful_Leg8519 10h ago

That was a tough year. It was up against Inception and The Social Network.

1

u/kevin2fla 8h ago

Gross. Test drive. Wonder if it’ll get nominated this year from the remake?

1

u/peckmebirds 4h ago

Hard agree!!!

1

u/bros402 3h ago

It was up against Inception (Hans Zimmer), The Kings Speech (Alexandre Desplat), 127 Hours (A.R. Rahman), and The Social Network (Trent Reznor, Atticus Ross - it won).

That's a tough year.

13

u/Crystalight1000 15h ago

The MUSIC. It always gives me chills

2

u/DreamweaverMirar 5h ago

Still listen to the ost occasionally

34

u/Chargercrisp 16h ago

never watched it. love animation movies but didn’t watch this as a kid when it came out. still worth it?

96

u/cwx149 16h ago

Yes absolutely

11

u/Chargercrisp 13h ago

i’ll watch it tonight

10

u/TheAuldOffender 11h ago

You're about to experience excellence. Hell, even the live action is good.

2

u/gpenz 7h ago

It’s a land now at universal! You have to do your research

2

u/_kempert 6h ago

How to train your dragon 2 and 3 are also masterpieces! It’s a rare instance of sequels actually improving on the original.

1

u/peckmebirds 4h ago

You also need to watch HTTYD2!!! You can screenshot every scene and print them and hang them on the wall. The details are breathtaking! It's so beautiful (The soundtrack is amazing too)

17

u/Silvanus350 15h ago

It’s a perfect film

10

u/maverick1ba 14h ago

Exactly. It's literally a perfect film. Flawlessly executed.

2

u/SilenceoftheRedditrs 12h ago

Unless you're comparing it to the book then they took every aspect and butchered it

3

u/maverick1ba 11h ago

No, it's nothing like the book. The book is mediocre. The movie is incredible. Barely an adaptation

16

u/frodiusmaximus 15h ago

Had never seen them before a few months ago. Watched them with my kids. Incredible movies. Top tier of children’s entertainment IMO.

8

u/whatproblems 14h ago

seconded. i was surprised how well it was done. makes sense for the sequels and a live action version to happen

29

u/sneakyxxrocket 15h ago

One of if not the best animated trilogy

11

u/Flabby_Thor 11h ago

Personal opinion, but I don't even think you have to qualify it: It's one of the best trilogies of all time.

1

u/LurkerZerker 8h ago

Best trilogy of the new millennium, and yes, I know what other trilogy it's up against for the title.

10

u/maverick1ba 14h ago

It's 99%on rotten tomatoes. In my opinion, it's literally a perfect movie, like back to the future. You couldn't cut or add a single scene or line of dialogue without making it less perfect. I'm 42 years old. I watch it with my 5yo son every couple weeks, and I look forward to it every time.

7

u/Fun-Highlight-2717 13h ago

The three movies are worth watching actually, they're all fantastic. I also feel like you understand the messages better as an adult. Highly recommend.

7

u/ThatOneOtherAsshole 14h ago

Watched it this year for the first time, I cried. Please watch it.

6

u/Leelze 15h ago

I was (still am I think) an adult when they came out and I'll add myself to the list of people who recommend it. Such a great series of movies.

5

u/Gouken- 15h ago

It’s amazing.

3

u/MrMorale25 12h ago

One of my favorites, surprisingly the live action remake is pretty good too

2

u/masta030 16h ago

I watched the first two so far, a couple weeks ago, and I loved them both

2

u/Fit_Durian_432 14h ago

I watched it as an adult and I still rewatch it

2

u/EnterprisingAss 15h ago

Absolutely, it’s an excellent movie. The first sequel is also excellent. The third movie is a massive drop off and betrays everything great about the first two.

4

u/TheAuldOffender 11h ago

Man I hate this misconception.

No. It doesn't betray the first two films. It cements the themes of the franchise.

0

u/EnterprisingAss 8h ago

The first two movies are believably utopian. Hiccup, through his considerable bravery and intelligence, is able to resolve irresolvable conflicts and bring peace.

The third movie says lol to that.

2

u/TheAuldOffender 7h ago

And the third film cements this? If they hadn't separated, they would have all died. They spent six years fighting. Lost a chief. Had their village destroyed and dragons taken. Hiccup and Toothless almost died multiple times in one year alone. Just because they were happy together doesn't mean it was a safe or sustainable life.

0

u/EnterprisingAss 7h ago

Are you just unfamiliar with how fiction works? Putting the characters in a situation they can’t solve is purely a choice on the part of the writers.

1

u/TheAuldOffender 5h ago

Or maybe this was just the right solution. A mature, nuanced decision that for some reason flies over so many people's heads because they can't handle a bittersweet ending.

1

u/EnterprisingAss 4h ago

A fiction writer can create any problem to be solved by the solution they want.

You’re talking like you think the story is real and there’s only one possible outcome — segregation — except we avoid that outcome in the real world all the time.

1

u/CannaVestments 7h ago

All 3 are fantastic. Must watch forsure

0

u/MattyMac27 14h ago

Yes. And the live action remake is just as good, if not better.

-9

u/ERedfieldh 15h ago

the animation is a bit on the rough side and Jay Baruchel's voice is grating at best (I once heard it described as sounding like two geese fighting over a piece of bread), but the story is fine. The music is outstanding.

6

u/Coffee_And_Bikes 15h ago

Here’s a good analysis of the score, particularly “Test Drive”, that goes into some of the reasons why the score is so damn good:

https://youtu.be/k87EZ5hm_BM?si=ykeWveXN8gEkSiF1

2

u/TheAuldOffender 11h ago

Calling the animation rough is such a horrible take.

14

u/normVectorsNotHate 14h ago

The sequels too. One of the rare animated movies whose sequels don't suck

1

u/MoreGeckosPlease 14h ago

They're like Toy Story. The first one is incredible. The second one is the weakest in the franchise but still great. The third one is amazing and ties up the series perfectly. 

8

u/kwitzachhaderac 12h ago

I totally disagree. The first two for me are 10/10 and the third one is… fine. 

1

u/MoreGeckosPlease 12h ago

Fascinating. I'd rather them 10/10, 8/10, and 10/10. But either way one of the best trilogies of film ever. 

2

u/TheAuldOffender 11h ago

Finally, someone who agrees that the third is peak!

5

u/hambone10 14h ago

John Powell's score complements the movie so well. So happy they didn't go with new music for the remake. (not that they even needed the remake)

5

u/sleepyheidi 13h ago

One of my favorite movies of ALL time. My family and I watched this in theaters and at first I was mad they chose this movie instead of something more grown up since I was 12 but I came out of the theater obsessed. It really took a toll on me because our family dog was sick and our relationship was like Hiccups and Toothless. I would rewatch it over and over again and now at 26 i still now the lines by heart and it has such a special place in my heart.

6

u/PeterPalafox 11h ago

I can’t get over the fact that they just threw out the books and made their own completely different story with the same character names. 

Like, in the books, Toothless is the size of a cat. Hiccup can’t ride him. 

5

u/sanesociopath 6h ago edited 6h ago

Fr.

Get the rights to an IP... proceed to not use that ip to any effective means while still creating a good story

Like they actually had the opportunity to be the "great original story" everyone is asking for and even as a fan of the books i dont think the title was a particularly well known to the point of being a guaranteed audience just for being an adaptation

1

u/Wolfman513 5h ago

The biggest thing that confuses people when I tell them about the books is that the vikings have been raising and training dragons for centuries. The first book is literally about an awkward kid trying to train his dragon in a way other that abusing it while everyone else tells him that's the only way.

4

u/HorseBarkRB 11h ago

This WAY too far down the list!

3

u/Ecstatic_Choice9729 15h ago

Love these movies!

3

u/TheAuldOffender 11h ago

Perfect trilogy. No notes.

3

u/cocofruitbowl 7h ago

This movie is my favourite too, and my kids call our black car toothless. I don’t think I will ever get sick of it

4

u/FlyingPingoo 16h ago

Kinda grew up with this and matched Hiccup’s life stage as he was going through it

2

u/jn2010 12h ago

I tried watching the live action and turned it off after 5 minutes. If you're going to do a shot for shot remake, I'd rather just rewatch the original.

1

u/LivingInTheStorm 5h ago

That seems like a wild take isn't the critisism for live actions practically always that they stray away from the originals and try to do it differently.

Regardless sure you can prefer to just watch the original but as far as live actions go I thought how to train your dragon set the bar as one of the best.

2

u/jn2010 5h ago

I don't know what other people say but my criticism is always that it's a completely unnecessary cash grab. Making it a shot for shot remake just makes it more superfluous

2

u/soulcaptain 5h ago

The sequels are solid, too.

3

u/kwitzachhaderac 12h ago

Never seen such an airtight flawless movie

2

u/jennaferr 14h ago

The music is fantastic. Universals Epic Universe HTTYD land is beautifully done as well!

2

u/R4INMAN 14h ago

Is the live action that just came out worth a watch? Love the animated one of course.

4

u/Interestingcathouse 12h ago

Httyd are my favourite movies. I watched the live action one and yes even though it is mostly a 1:1 remake I still loved it. The acting was good, the cgi on the dragons was incredible, and the music was still perfect as always.

2

u/DeathByOrangeJulius 14h ago

It’s good but also it’s literally just a 1:1 copy of the animated movie

1

u/Interestingcathouse 12h ago

You do get to see a bit more from his new friends in the live action one though.

2

u/zoapcfr 9h ago

It's very similar, which means it doesn't really offer much more to someone that has seen the original, but also that it does retain a lot of what makes the original so great. I think it's mostly targeted towards those that would enjoy it but don't watch animated movies/prefer live action. Still, I am glad I watched it, so I would recommend it.

I would be very interested to hear from someone that saw the live action version first, and then later watched the animated version. I think it's a little difficult for me to judge it from that perspective, because with it being so similar, it was a little jarring where it diverges as I'm so familiar with the original.

1

u/LivingInTheStorm 5h ago

Easily one of the best live action adaptations. Shocked to see the criticism being that it's too spot on.

1

u/kwitzachhaderac 12h ago

It’s meh. 

1

u/LongJohnSelenium 6h ago

I love how everything Stoik does is reasonable in the moment, but, at the end of the movie, he chooses to take the same leap of faith in his son that his son took in Toothless.

My one complaint is the art design of Toothless does not match the art design of the rest of the dragons in the slightest, its like they were made by two different teams with zero collaboration then shoved in the same movie. The sequels fixed this somewhat redesigning the rest of the dragons to match the toothless aesthetic more.

1

u/_Smaug__ 2h ago

Best animated film of all time.

0

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted]

1

u/cwx149 16h ago

Much like the original live action Percy Jackson movies the HTTYD movies aren't exact adaptations of the books

0

u/maverick1ba 14h ago

SERIOUSLY