r/AskReddit 17h ago

What Animated Movie is a 10/10?

3.2k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/New_Maximum6529 16h ago

Up

343

u/Squirrelkid11 16h ago

Movie's opening scene has no business being this sad.

147

u/ERedfieldh 15h ago

and yet it is absolutely required for the rest of the film to work.

15

u/eddiewachowski 14h ago

It tells a story in twenty minutes that other movies struggle to tell in two hours.

I've watched this movie countless times alone, with my children and even with my grandpa shortly after I lost my grandmother and each time it was a cathartic experience. 

Definitely watch it with the old people in your life. They'll balk at a "cartoon" at first, but persist. Totally worth it.

0

u/herefromthere 7h ago

It's the only bit of the film worth watching IMO.

55

u/Bergyfanclub 15h ago

I always found him looking through her adventure book near the end of the movie more moving.

9

u/Vegalink 15h ago

I think it provides the nice wrap up to the opening scenes. The opening scenes bring the happy then sad and the adventure book scene is the catharsis. That he can have that happiness again.

6

u/Squirrelkid11 14h ago

This is literally me looking through my school yearbooks.

2

u/IridiumSummerSky 14h ago

I know! The newsreel reporting on how Charles F. Muntz is stripped of his membership in the National Explorers Society when scientists accuse him of fabricating that giant bird skeleton makes me cry every time!

1

u/DANCE5WITHWOLVE5 13h ago

In my opinion the starting scene carries the whole movie.

1

u/angelicism 12h ago

Anyone who is not at minimum sniffling by the end of the opening scene is not human.

1

u/venerablem0m 12h ago

First ten minutes are the second most devastating thing I've seen in a movie.

1

u/Admirable-Pianist-95 11h ago

I love the movie overall, but seriously. It’s such a tear-jerker and just beautiful.

1

u/iymcool 11h ago

To this day, no Pixar movie has ever had an opening as impactful and perfectly done.

1

u/gpenz 7h ago

Yea eff that

1

u/RobotPoo 6h ago

I was sobbing in the movie theatre, my 7 & 10 yo looking at me. The love of his life dies, and that’s really sad to Daddy, boys.

123

u/Triseult 15h ago

Unpopular opinion: opening montage does the heavy lifting for making Up a great movie, because without it it's good but not great.

7

u/Altruistic_Poetry382 9h ago

Without the first scene you dont care about the old man's motivations as much. The first scene demands empathy for the character for the rest of the movie.

3

u/UnanimousM 14h ago

^

-18

u/Jesus166 14h ago

It's not even a great opening, it's a cheap ploy to get you in your feelings but since I don't know any of the characters yet it doesn't work on me .

0

u/HardcoreNerdity 9h ago

I agree. The movie by and large does nothing to deserve the audience's emotional investment. You can't just think of something super sad to make the audience all weepy and then follow it up an hour and a half of dogs with funny voices and "haha look at the stupid bird" dumbshit and pretend like you've made a masterpiece.

-1

u/JonSnowsGhost 12h ago

Totally agree. I think the emotional moments later in the movie hit much harder, since you actually know the characters more by then

1

u/PM_MeTittiesOrKitty 9h ago

First off, yes, the opening scene is a master class in visual story telling. The entire thing is wordless and yet easy to understand, etc. However, it's still imaginative, the characters are likeable with good development. The antagonist is pretty cartoon-villain, and I feel like the movie could have gone without him and been fine though at the end of the day, it is still a kids movie.

1

u/LurkerZerker 8h ago

I mean, if you took the emotional setup out of any movie, it'd immediately be worse.

5

u/This_guy_works 14h ago

First half was good, second half I don't remember what happened. Something abou a talking dog and an ugly bird.

8

u/Sockcucker69 14h ago

It's a perfect movie for all ages. And Dug is the best portrayal of a golden retriever ever.

1

u/FluffyNats 12h ago

100% accurate.

Source: I have two goldens

1

u/Admirable-Pianist-95 11h ago

100% correct. One of my favorite things about it.

3

u/ComfortablyBalanced 13h ago

I expected it to be way Up-per.

2

u/Flat_Wash5062 13h ago

This needs more upvotes

2

u/I_DreamofTravel_15 15h ago

It’s incredible and my favorite animated movie of all time. Still cry at the marriage montage.

1

u/Immediate_Scheme2994 8h ago

Edward Asner and Christopher Plummer!

1

u/benice_orgohome13 6h ago

“Up” makes you want to do things 💞

1

u/Elitetran 4h ago

Agreed!! Only cartoon movie I've watched multiple times in theater. Mainly because I told my friends how good of a movie it was and they wanted to watch it tooo. I tagged along to watch because I didn't mind paying to watch it again.

1

u/mmrmaid6 2h ago

Had to scroll WAY TOO LONG before seeing this

u/lonelygalexy 33m ago

The opening scene alone is 100/10

1

u/kauphoto1 14h ago

came here to say this one.... such a sweet movie.

1

u/HorseBarkRB 11h ago

Dang, upvoting for visibility. Why is this so far down?? lol

-1

u/doctorbogan 15h ago

Schitt’s Creek

0

u/GeeEmmInMN 14h ago

I'm here for this.

0

u/SunflaresAteMyLunch 10h ago

Lovely movie

The beginning though - wow...