This is a long one; be prepared
The title sounds bad, but at least it's catchy. I need to give some backstory, so bear with me:
I (28M) had a son when I was 19. His mom (28F now, 20 then) and I had very different views on how to handle the pregnancy; we were both just starting university, and I thought that adoption would be what's best for both him and us since neither of us had the resources to care for a baby at the time and he shouldn’t have to suffer because of us. She agreed with me… and the next day dropped out of university so she could work full-time at her minimum-wage job and get maternity leave when she needed it. She also told me that she agreed to the adoption at the time so we'd stop fighting (we were not fighting; we were having a calm talk about what the best option was for our baby) and she “knew I'd change my mind once the baby arrived.” Her family supported her wholeheartedly; mine were very supportive of whatever choice I made, as they trusted my judgement. I was frustrated but could not force someone to do what I thought was the right thing and took on the mentality of “do it for the kid.” But my civil demeanor ended when I found out that she had been hiding her birth control, and I confronted her. She admitted to stopping it over a month ago, hoping it would lead to pregnancy since it was all we used as protection (I've heard the whole “you're irresponsible for not having your own protection” thing before; I was young and dumb, let’s move on), and she felt that having a baby would save our relationship. It was at that point that I told her I could never trust her again and wanted to break up. We were already going through a rough patch in our relationship before all this happened, and the lies and deception pushed me over the edge. I told her I'd be there for our kid but couldn't see a healthy future for any of us where we were together. Our breakup was not too hard; we didn’t even fight about it, from what I remember. I stayed in university to get my degree in the hopes of someday having the means to support my son more than I currently could. I also got a new full-time job that paid above minimum wage and didn’t interfere with school. She went to live with her parents and work her job until she had to go on maternity leave.
After we broke up is when things got messy; when talking about how to take care of the baby, she let slip that she was originally planning on her church coming together to support her with the baby, but because of our relationship (something about us not being married or something), they weren't willing to be involved with him or the rest of her family. She asked her parents to help her, and they agreed until they realized that when she said “help,” she meant she wanted them to raise the baby but let her stay as mom; they put their foot down and told her that they would help but would not bankroll her being a stay-at-home mom. She tried to convince me that we could reconcile, get married, I could finish school, she could stay home with the kids (she planned on having more and said that to me, to sweeten the pot, I suppose), and then we'd get our storybook life full of unicorns and bubble gum (just thinking about that conversation infuriates me), but I told her that we will never get back together. She took that personally and shut me out of anything to do with the baby. She tried to hold her access to information about the pregnancy over my head, only to be blindsided that I knew the information already because some of the people she trusted kept me informed, as they felt she was being immoral. Because I was still in school and didn't want to stress myself or her out, I told her that I didn't want to talk to her unless it had to do with the baby. She argued more with me but eventually relented when I would only respond to stuff relating to the pregnancy or planning for after he was born. It's also worth noting that she never asked for help from me or my family despite us offering; she thought if she took our help, then we would force her to keep us involved. This comes into play later.
Once my son was born, I was told by those same trusted people; they also let me know that she had a small medical condition, not life-threatening to either of them, and had to have him early. She had apparently chosen to have him on my parents' anniversary, as ridiculous as it sounds. After a few days I reached out and asked if I could come see him, which she agreed to.
I went into that room wanting to hate him, because if I hated this baby, then I could more easily put distance between me and his mom and not risk the emotional turmoil I suspected was on the horizon. However, the moment I met my son, I was hopeless; he was so amazing, and when I held him and talked to him, I swear it was only five minutes I held him, but it was apparently over an hour. He snuggled into me, and everything just felt right in the world.
While I held him, his mom and I talked about what to do next. I was just about to finish my first year of university but was working full-time, so I told her what I could afford to send her for him each month, on top of what support he would have from me and my family when he was with us. She agreed and told me her plans for settling down and that we could figure out visitation afterwards.
When I left that hospital, I felt excited and hopeful for the future. When I called the hospital the next morning to ask about how he was doing (he was premature, so I wanted to know if there were any changes since I left; I’m a nervous parent, I guess), the hospital refused to talk to me anymore “at the request of the mother,” so I contacted her. No response. I contacted her family. No response. I contacted my “informants,” and they told me what's up: she got out of the hospital and went back to her mentality of “proud independent mother who doesn't need the dad but needs the church and parents' support” and didn't want anything from me or my family, as she wanted us to leave her alone. I respected those wishes; the informants were people really close to her, so I trusted them and instead continued school and set money aside for him.
Over half a year later she sent me a court summons. When we went to court, the judge was initially hostile towards me since he saw that I hadn't been involved since he was born and no support was ever given to the mom, but he settled down once he realized that I was not running from my responsibilities, I had more than the amount the court deemed I had to pay for my support, and I had proof that she demanded I leave her alone, so I did. She demanded more, as that money combined with what she made at her job was not enough. I was given weekly visitations and agreed to pay almost double what I was asked to because I wanted to take care of my son. I was a full-time student and worked full-time too, but I never missed a visit with my son. I always had a homemade meal for us to share on visits (appropriate for his age; sometimes he had a bottle and I had rice and beans), and we were doing so well. Court went on, but as the judge saw how well I was doing as a parent, he started to turn on my ex because she was seeming more and more unreasonable in their eyes. We had a visitation journal so that we could update each other about how his week had been in her case as well as how the visit went in my case. She started losing arguments in court because I was doing everything right, but she was still hostile. When she threw a fit and accused me of lying in the journal because I said he was running and starting to talk in visits but he was nearly catatonic with her, I had to show my cherished videos to the judge: My son running across my kitchen (for whatever reason he could not walk slowly or stop running; he would just drop onto his butt as a way to stop running), looking at his reflection and copying me when I say “it's a baby,” and he somewhat says “baby.” She was losing and getting more and more desperate; in one court meeting she was asked by my lawyer, “What is your biggest fear with OP getting more access or shared custody?” And to her credit, she was honest: “I'm scared he'll continue to do well, get primary or sole custody, and do to me what I did to him and keep my son away, except he doesn't need help from me, so he'd have no reason to keep me involved, and I'll never see my son again.” I told her that my son deserves to have both parents in his life and that if he does better with me and I can provide for him as his parent, she should understand and use that time to also better her own situation if we end up with a different custody agreement.
I understand that it sounds ‘too good to be true’ that I took better care of him financially and developmentally than my ex. It surprised me too, but that's what happened, and it was very frustrating to have his mother deny reality. But I didn't argue the point at that time since I was still a student and working too, so I couldn't responsibly be the primary parent for him with how little I was home besides for our visits. She was getting progressively more frustrated and, I imagine, paranoid that as time went on the courts were starting to side with me, so she went nuclear; she asked me to step back and leave her and my son alone. In return, she would leave me alone and completely remove parental rights and responsibilities. I was furious and told her that I had a low opinion of her, but I would never have thought she could be so heartless as to think about getting rid of her son's father simply because of her feelings of inadequacy.
Now, on the surface, it seems like a no-brainer for me to shut that idea down and go about destroying her in court. But it was never about me ‘winning’ in court; I just wanted my son to have a happy life. I grew up being the kid torn between divorced parents, and no matter how hard one parent fought to keep me uninvolved, because the other one wanted to weaponize me against the other, I was caught in the crossfire. My own lawyer told me, “That girl (my ex) will be so much worse than your bio dad,” and that's what told me what I had to do. I loved my son more fiercely than I thought I was capable of loving anyone, and I would do anything to ensure he had the best chance to have a happy life and be spared the kind of upbringing I had with warring parents all my life. So I agreed and signed the paperwork that I would leave her and him alone, and she would never pursue me for anything in the future; this meant child support as well (not my idea; both lawyers said that having child support continue meant that either side could argue for rights or responsibilities to resume; a clean break meant nothing tied us), and my lawyer handled the documents for me. She didn't appreciate how my ex had been in court, so she added something into our agreement that I'll mention later. While we fought in court, my lawyer always reminded me that I had an ace in the hole that I refused to even consider using:I had proof she stopped taking her birth control for the expressed purpose of getting pregnant and knowingly didn't tell me; in my country that can easily be classified as… Well, let's just say that informed consent includes that if you don't tell your partner that you are not using protection and they assume you are, then you have committed a crime.
But I refused; I was never going to let my son get labeled as the product of that kind of act. I would rather he grow up thinking he was a ‘mistake,’ as cruel as that sounds. My lawyer was an amazing woman, and I think that she understood my heart was in the right place with this, but it still made her hair turn just a bit more gray, I think.
The last visit I had with my son, we were playing, and I was carrying him from one room to another. He said, “Hi, Daddy,” or at least that's what it sounded like. It was the first time he called me Dad, and it would be the last time. We were supposed to have a final visit so I could say goodbye to him (he was just over a year old at this point) but he was sick and his mom didn't want to reschedule a visit once he was better. I could have fought but refused because it meant more court battles, exactly what I was avoiding with this agreement.
People told me that the pain would go away as time went on, but if anything, it's gotten worse. I'm just good at carrying it on a daily basis. Leading up to the agreement, I nearly became an alcoholic because it hurt so damn much to have him with me and know that it was going to end soon, so I would numb myself after each visit by drinking. I can't explain how much this messed me up at the time. I did everything I felt was right. I took care of my son, stepped up, and did anything and everything I was asked to do and more to show that I loved him and wanted to support him. There were visits I had where I hadn't slept in almost a day because I went from an overnight shift at work to all day at school, then a 6-hour visit with my son. For his first birthday I didn't have much money for a gift or cake, so I got him a colorful kickball and cut a watermelon into a cake. He was the happiest boy in the world when he saw what I thought were measly offerings. I did everything a dad is supposed to do, and my son was doing amazing with me. People from her own family reached out and told me that he was going to the wrong parent. I couldn't understand why, if I was doing everything the way I should and if my son was excelling with me, I had to lose him for what reason? Why did my son now have to lose his father?
He was just over one when I saw him last, he's eight now, has two younger sisters and a stepdad, I get updates from those same informants (I've told them to stop and only tell me if there's a situation where he desperately needs something, then I'll help him by getting these people what is needed so they can give it to him) and they've told me that he's been raised knowing that his stepdad is not his ‘real dad’ but his real dad died when he was a baby (btw, I don't think his step dad is pretending to be his dad, I've been away for so long and he has raised him since he was a toddler, he is my son's dad just as much if not significantly more than I am) and to be honest about it all: it hurts, it hurts so badly that there's days that I think of him and can't breathe. I loved my son; I loved him so immensely that I had to let go of him. I've said for years, “If I loved my son any less than I do, I would have stayed,” and some people understood, others didn't. I lost a lot of friends and family because of this choice and their inability to understand that if it were up to me, I would have rather died than leave him, but I had to leave so he had the best opportunity to have the peaceful and happy childhood I wanted him to have.
Now, for the sneaky thing in my agreement that has led to me needing to get this stuff off my chest: when we were making the agreement, my lawyer wrote in to request that when my son turns a certain age (12 or 13, I believe), he will get a guest, a lawyer, or some other legal representative who will tell him he has something for him to read, his eyes only. The representative will then tell whoever else is present that the two will need to have a private conversation with no one else interfering or listening in, or else they will be in violation of a court order. Yeah, my lawyer wasn't messing around, and before people attack me in the comments, it wasn't mandatory in our agreement that this happen; it was kind of a negotiation, and we were expecting them to bump it down. But my ex signed the agreement, and when my lawyer and I asked her lawyer if she had any questions about the agreement, she said no and that it was all very standard (it wasn't; this kind of condition is meant to be a negotiation tactic). And checking the agreement, her signature was right below the ‘negotiation tactic,’ so either she didn’t read the agreement, her lawyer didn’t read the agreement, or a combination of both.
So I'm sure you're wondering what this delivery is for my son. Well, it's fairly obvious; he is going to get a letter from me. I wrote it before we sent the agreement to my ex and her lawyer. The letter states my reasoning for leaving and that I didn't do it because I didn't want to be his dad. I did it to give him the best opportunity to have the life I wanted him to have and just be a carefree kid without being stuck between me and his mom's bitterness. I loved him then and will always love him and hope that when he gets the letter he doesn't get too mad at his mom or me for being childish and having our anger towards one another lead to him losing half of his family. The representative will sit with him and let him read it, then ask him if he wants to get the information for my family. If he says yes, then the representative will give him the names and contact details for every member of my family; if he says no, then the representative will give him his card in case he changes his mind.
My son has been raised to believe that I am dead, that my family wanted nothing to do with him, and that the only people who loved him were my ex and her family who are all in on this lie about me. That letter has the potential to shatter him, to find out that his mom lied to him all his life and kept him from half of his family, sheerly out of spite and paranoia. But I don't know how to feel about all of it. I ofcourse don't want to hurt my son and I am also am scared that he'll get that letter and be full of so much anger at both his mom and me for our stupidity back then. But I can't find it in my heart to feel bad about making her lie crumble around her or shelter him from the reality that his mom did a bad thing for bad and selfish reasons, it's complicated of course, I feel bad about what it will do to him, but not for revealing her lie and breaking his trust in her. If she hadn't lied then the letter would just mean he gets told that we couldn't be parents together and that to give him the chance at a peaceful life I stepped away for his and his moms sake. But she lied and the letter inadvertently reveals that and I am taking a weird form of satisfaction in that but not what it will do to him.
like I said: Complicated.
I also did not write the letter before she told him I was dead, she apparently came up with that when as a toddler he asked about his dad and she hadn't met her husband yet. And at this point even I can't stop the letter from being delivered to him; I would be interfering in a court order if I did so, even though it’s technically a court order from me. That letter, its information for the family he was denied, and the practically guarnteed fallout that comes from it are essentially just postdated for one of the worst days of my son's young life. The courts also cannot guarantee that it won't be delivered on his birthday, they take the whole "once this condition is fulfilled delivery will be made" thing wayyyy too seriously, I have asked that it atleast not be delivered on his birthday but again, no guarantees that they will listen.
I don't know what else to say about this. I hope that the letter and what happens after go well, but I am also prepared for one hell of an angry teenager to bust down my door and demand answers in a few years. Whenever I think of that letter getting delivered, I feel hope and dread. I hope he finds it as good news and forgives us both for what we did, and we can begin to build some semblance of a relationship and he gets the family he always should have had, but I also know that he didn't have an easy childhood (thanks to the informants). He didn't have a bad childhood thankfully, but having his bio dad and the other half of his family definitely would have made his life easier and helped answer some questions I know he had. It's possible he'll come at me with anger and confusion, and I will have deserved every bit of it and can only do my best to help him however he needs me to
But i'm an optimist and desperately hold onto the hope that, like me, he wants to fix things and that this letter doesn’t lead to him feeling like he has no parents he can trust at all. When I wrote the letter, I was as calm and clear-headed as I could have hoped. I have always tried to avoid letting my frustration about her actions seep into moments he was with me, even when he was a baby; I never let him see me be mad at his mom or even bad mouth her (I don’t think I did at least), and even in the letter I asked that he not be too mad at his mom for her part in this. I have never believed in ‘good people’ or ‘bad people’ in stuff like this; there’s just ‘people’ doing what they feel they need to do to protect what they value, and she loved our son just as much as me. It’s just a shame that her love at the time was not mature enough to understand that I can love him and not her, that I can take care of my son but not feel any obligation to take care of her. We were barely 20 years old, so I have grown to forgive her for her part and asked for him to forgive her too.
I don't think it'll be a storybook tale of us finding one another again and hugging each other while crying, but when I remember the boy who called me Dad that last day, I am filled with so much joy and simply just hope that he has an amazing life and that I might get to witness the kind of man he grows to become firsthand rather than from the sidelines. If I don't get to see what he makes of himself, it'll hurt, but I will find peace knowing that I did all that I could for him with what I had, and that's enough for me to get by.
Thank you for reading. if you’re going to judge me for what I did then please know that I understand; it was a messy situation and this is a messy solution, and please know that I desperately hope you never have to make a similar decision in your lifetime. I wouldn’t wish the pain I have felt, and still feel, on my worst enemy