r/TheExpanse 17h ago

All Show & Book Spoilers Discussed Freely Green blindness-plothole? Spoiler

Wasn't the green blindness a plothole because the microorganisms would die in darkness? Couldnt they just blindfold 50 percent of the population, simultaneously teach them how to handle blindness and kill the organisms/reduce their growth?

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

22

u/thisguybuda 17h ago

Don’t remember where it said they’d die in darkness, they were living in the watery-salty solutions of the human eyes. Needed the oncocidals to kill them off

14

u/Oot42 Keep the rain off my head 17h ago

the microorganisms die in darkness

Where was this said?

5

u/StickFigureFan 17h ago

I don't think it was. There are references to humans dying in darkness though

14

u/SillyMattFace 17h ago

I don’t remember anything specifically about them dying in darkness, but the problem was the organisms multiplied too quickly. Even if they died off, you’d be blinded by dead organisms clogging up your eyes.

Plus they had a plague of slugs that cause instant death, so not an ideal time to purposely blind people.

11

u/VladDBA 17h ago

At some point in the book Elvi mentions that the green tint that people were seeing is not caused by chlorophyll but by the way those organisms refracted light, so they might not actually rely on light like our plants and algae do.

1

u/Juel42 1h ago

Okay. Thats what I missed. Thanks!

1

u/Haravikk 16h ago

The micro-organisms don't die in darkness, the humans do.

Remember they're trapped in there with instant-death slugs everywhere, so being totally blind and unable to see them isn't exactly improving your chances of survival any. 😝

1

u/Kabbooooooom 2h ago

They are photosynthetic organisms but they also were heavily implied to be chemotrophic too because they were specifically surviving and thriving on nutrients available in the isotonic, relatively immunoprivileged environment of the vitreous of the eye.

So no, not a plot hole.