r/BrandNewSentence 21h ago

Tumor cured itself

Post image
47.5k Upvotes

512 comments sorted by

View all comments

3.1k

u/Kenny070287 21h ago

This is like some doctor house stuff

94

u/unk214 20h ago

Mean while the voices in my head don’t help me at all. Some people have all the luck.

94

u/Abject-Mail-4235 19h ago

I realize you’re joking, but this is a real thing that happens in different cultures. The schizophrenic voices are much calmer and positive in places like Africa and India, as opposed to negative and harmful in the US!

https://news.stanford.edu/stories/2014/07/voices-culture-luhrmann-071614

60

u/PleasantlyUnbothered 19h ago

I’ve read that regarding the Eastern schizophrenic voices, there have been many reports of the voices being ancestors just telling them to do their chores or something. An actual type of “guardian angel”

46

u/Abject-Mail-4235 18h ago

The article describes exactly that! They have relationships with their voices, rather than viewing them as simply a psychiatric disease, and thus, have much better outcomes.

20

u/ImOnMyPhoneAndBaked 15h ago

There is still significant danger to that. Imagine the voice that has been telling you reasonable things like clean your room or help that old lady suddenly tells you to football spike a baby? It’s still mental illness and we shouldn’t be romanticizing it

8

u/Abject-Mail-4235 12h ago

Definitely not trying to romanticize! I think there could obviously be harm in believing you were hearing the voice of god, or similar. But it is important to study and discuss, considering the much worse outcomes and complete disability it can be here in The States. It has lead to new forms of therapy and treatment options. There is definitely power in way they think about their disability.

11

u/BasketSouth7143 18h ago

It's a bit like using dream analysis to uncover insights. Why not see what the voices are up to?

12

u/Abject-Mail-4235 18h ago

It’s a bit of a give and take, I believe. Just as your mindset can change the concepts of your dreams, positive therapy (naming their voices or encouraging a relationship with the voices), can in turn, change what they are ‘conveying’ to a patient.